Introduction
Like the dots which are connected to produce a picture, the clarity of the image depends on the correct location of the dots. Similarly, the profile and the significance of the achievements of a great leader depend on the accuracy of the events and dates relating to him. The same is true when we meditate on the incredible achievements and personality of Guru Gobind Singh as a spiritual preceptor, poet, peerless saint-warrior, nation-builder and a living martyr who sacrificed his entire family (sarbans daan) for his beloved Khalsa and for the freedom of his country.
Confirmation of the accuracy of Sikh chronicles is the first challenge for a student of Sikh history. Fortunately, dedicated research by scholars in recent time has made available contemporary records denied to earlier students of Sikh history and we are beginning to get a clearer picture of important events and dates.
This article touches on some aspects of Guru Gobind Singh's life and mission from different perspectives in the light of more recent research. The aim is to give pointers to further lines of inquiry. Nevertheless, the continuity of Guru Nanak Sahib's mission through worthy successors to Guru Gobind Singh ji, becomes self-evident.
The great importance of the Guruships of Guru Har Rai and Guru Har Krishan (Seventh and Eight Nanaks respectively) during a crucial period in Gur-ithaas (Guru history) in the essential continuity of Guru Nanak Sahibs mission is for another discussion.
Nirmala literature and Bhat vahis (chronicles)
Before discussing Guru Gobind Singh's response to the challenges he faced on being consecrated Nanak X, it would be worthwhile to understand the underlying reasons for the confusion about events and dates in Sikh historyii. That is, other than the obvious reason that Sikhs have been too busy making history rather than recording it!
Gur Partap Suraj, popularly known as Suraj Parkash, is the magnus opus of the great poet Bhai Santokh Singh, doyen of the Nirmala Sectiii. It describes in sakhi (anecdotal) style the lives of the nine Gurus after Guru Nanak Sahib and was completed in 1843. It is recited regularly in gurdwaras and is popular with preachers and Sikh historians alike. The Nirmala tradition interpreted Sikh ideology and episodes relating to the lives of the Gurus through the lens of Vedic literatureiv. Accuracy of events and correct dates was given lower priority. Many would regard any questioning of the strong Vedic influence or the accuracy of the episodes described in Suraj Parkash as poetic as well as religious sacrilege.
In contrast were the records kept by generations of Bhat scholars and poets and Panda genealogists. Their livelihood depended on keeping these records. They had no reason to give any ideological bias to the records they kept. However, it is true that many Bhats became dedicated Sikhs of the Guru. Some Bhats wrote poetic eulogy for the Gurus and described Guru succession up to Guru Arjan (Fifth Nanak). It was sanctified in Guru Granth Sahib as Bhat Bani. Thus, it can be said that the Bhat records enjoyed recognition by the Gurus. The records kept by the Bhats about the Guru families and important episodes, including rites of passage, can be cross-checked with Panda vahisv, and give much more reliable contemporary evidence than Nirmala literature.
Therefore, although this is a topic which should be approached with caution, in recent years, due to research by scholars like late Prof. Piara Singh Padam, contemporary records kept by the Bhat poets and Panda genealogists have been made available to research students. One historical source is Guru Kian Sakhian by Bhai Sarup Singh Koshish and published by Prof. Piara Singh Padamvi. This is an invaluable source for cross checking dates and events and enables more objective interpretation of these.
In his introduction, Prof Padam points to the need for further research into the dates of birth of some Gurus including the date of birth of Guru Gobind Singh.
Guru Gobind Singh's date of birth
For example, it would certainly affect our interpretation and understanding of Guru Gobind Singh ji's response to the many challenges he faced when he succeeded Guru Tegh Bahadur as the Tenth Nanak, if we knew with some certainty that he was a few years older at the time than traditionally believed.
As late Prof Piara Singh Padam noted in his introduction to Guru Kian Sakhian, contemporary evidence of Bhat Vahis needs further research to determine the dates of birth of the Gurus. It is probable that both, Guru Hargobind and Guru Gobind Das were some years older than traditionally believed when they succeeded to Guruship.
Regarding Guru Gobind Singh's date of birth, evidence of Sakhi number 14 in Guru Kian Sakhian is relevant:
"Sri Tegh Bahadur ji, at the age of 35 years, on the day of Samat 1713 Asad Sudi Ekam started his tirath yatra ( pilgrimage) from Kot Guru Har Rai. When Sri Guru Har Rai ji passed away he [Tegh Bahadur] with family was in Patna. Here on Samat 1718 Pokh Massay Sudi Saptmi on Wednesday Gobind Das was born. Being far away from Punjab he did not get news of the demise of Guru Har Rai ji sooner. For that reason he came to Delhi and then Punjab in 1721 to condole with the family."
(translated from Punjabi by the author).
A rough conversion of the Bikrami (Indian calendar) years mentioned above gives year 1656 CE as the year when Tegh Bahadur started the tour of north-eastern Indian subcontinent, year 1661 as the year of birth of Gobind Das (Guru Gobind Singh) and year 1664 as the year when he returned to Punjab via Delhi. Prof. Piara Singh Padam confirms that this was a prolonged tour and Guru Gobind Singh was born during the later part of this tour at Patna on Poh Sudi Saptmi in year 1718 Bikrami. That gives Guru Gobind Singh's date of birth as 18 December 1661vii.
Although, the Sikh belief is that the Guru Jote-Jugat succession is not related to age. Nevertheless, age and physical aspects do assume importance in view of the challenges faced by the young successors of the two martyr Gurus, Guru Arjan and Guru Tegh Bahadur i.e. Guru Hargobind and Guru Gobind Singh respectively.
When Guru Tegh Bahadur returned from his preaching tour of north and eastern India by 1670, the family stayed together at Lakhnaur, a town near Ambala in Haryana, for some time and later toured the Malwa and Bangar countryside (areas between Sutlej and Delhi). Gobind Das (later Guru Gobind Singh) accompanied him on these preaching tours and was in his early teens at the time if Bhat Vahi evidence is accepted. Before that he had highly educational experience with the moving vaheerviii for some months when travelling from Patna to reach Lakhnaur on 13 September 1670.
He was deeply touched by Guru Tegh Bahadur's Bani as the latter took Guru Nanak's egalitarian message far and wide to the ordinary people. He discussed the plight of the Brahmin representatives led by Kashmiri Pandits with Guru Tegh Bahadur before the latter's departure for Delhi to meet emperor Aurungzeb. He fully understood the nationwide impact and far-reaching consequences of Guru Tegh Bahadur's unique martyrdom mentioned in the Bani traditionally attributed to him.
By that age he would also have been well trained by the Guru himself in the use of arms, horse riding and huntingix. Guru Tegh Bahadur had excelled at the battle of Kartarpur at the age of 14 years in 1635. Chronicles show that he had always kept up his interest in hunting and the use of armsx. In fact, he was out hunting with some Sikhs when he was first arrested at Dhamtan on 8 November 1665.
Vedic literature in people's language
Young Guru Gobind Dasxi, initiated as Guru Gobind Singh on the Khalsa Vaisakhi Day of 1699, took over the great responsibility of Guru Nanak's gaddi (seat of Guruship) as the Tenth Nanak, following the martyrdom of his father, Guru Tegh Bahadur, at Delhi in 1675. His grandfather, Guru Hargobind (Sixth Nanak), too had faced similar challenges on accession to the Gurgaddi following the martyrdom of his father, Guru Arjan, in 1606. So, both Guruships faced similar external threats following Guru martyrdoms, and in both cases the need was felt to protect the garden of Sikhi with the spiky fence of arms.
The strategy followed by Guru Gobind Das was to awaken and energise a downtrodden people by reminding them of their own great Indic heritage. The analogy would be that of a great saint-warrior arriving amongst a humiliated and divided people living in fear of tyrannical rule and seeking help. The Pandits of Kashmir leading a deputation which included heads of other Hindu centres in India, had sought such help from Guru Tegh Bahadur.
Guru Gobind Singh decided to awaken the dormant spirit of the ordinary people by making available to them literature in the language they understood about the great deeds of their own folk heroes: the mythical gods and goddesses, who (in their belief system) were the forces of good who had fought and destroyed the forces of evilxii. He would use the ordinary language of the people, a medium hitherto forbidden to the lower classes by the high priests, and not the complex language and mantras in Sanskrit reserved for the high castes only. Guru Gobind Das had a precedent to follow: Guru Nanak Sahib also had liberally used folklore and popular idiom in Gurbani, albeit, imparting new meanings to preach love of One Timeless Unborn (existing without birth or beginning) Creator Being before Whom all were equal and in Whose service no sacrifice was too great.
By doing so, the Guru would unite and rouse the masses and start a people's freedom movement. However, he was well aware that in the process he would also antagonise the priests and the kings of the very people he would be helping. Therefore, it is not surprising that the first test of his armed resistance was against the hill chiefs who had forgotten their true dharam (duty) to protect and look after the well-being of their own people. He denounced the priestly class, the biprans, who misled and exploited the ordinary people.
At the same time, he also offer the people the choice to join the path followed by his Sikhs. That path required great sacrifice, death defying courage and total dedication to the worship of One Supreme Timeless Being.
That is one strategy which Guru Gobind Singh followed. Encouraged by him, scholars and poets flocked to him and wrote about the heroes of folklore. He encouraged translation of Vedic literature so that it could be demystified and people could understand it.
The literature associated with Guru Gobind Singh should be seen in its proper context as above, as a means of awakening the people to their own past which showed the triumph of good over evil. Yet, in another sense, it also exposed the content of ancient myth and lore to the scrutiny of the more discerning. Many decided to give up the old ways to join the expanding ranks of the Guru's mar-jeevra (reborn) Khalsa. From Guru Nanak Sahib onwards, the Guru Jote (divine Light) warned that Sikhi demanded one's ego-centric head! Sikhi was a challenging and difficult path of love and sacrifice to follow. A Path of detachment and yet fully participative in the Creators world-play. It rejected the opt-out lifestyle of the Indic systems.
The Guru's mission
As the true successor of Guru Nanak Sahib, the Guru was the chosen instrument of the Timeless Being with the mission to destroy evil and to protect the saintly and the downtrodden. Presented in these terms, a parallel connection between his mission and the deeds of the ancient Indic heroes was made in the people's psyche. It motivated them to make great sacrifices under his lead in their just war against subjugation and all sorts of persecution.
Guru Tegh Bahadur's teachings and supreme sacrifice for the universal right to follow one's chosen religious path had left a deep impression on Guru Gobind Singh.
While Guru Tegh Bahadur's teachings bear witness to the truths enunciated by Guru Nanak and his successors and the conformity of Guru Tegh Bahadur to their religious ideology - there is a new dimension, a new note of urgency, and a sense of intense concern. Life is short; it hastens away; but it provides opportunity for those who would take it. Participation without entanglement is ideal, which can be realized only through conquest of fear. The idea is not altogether new, but the insistence is. The Sikhs are asked to acknowledge him alone as truly wise who is not afraid of others and who inspires no fear in others. Himself prepared for the worst eventualities, Guru Tegh Bahadur wanted others also to face life with couragexiii.
For Guru Gobind Singh, his own mission had been made clear to him by his father Guru Tegh Bahadur as he was making preparation to go to Delhi to confront the emperor Aurungzeb with his policy of religious bigotry. Guru Arjan Sahib also had instructed his son Guru Hargobind about the need for armed defence before he was martyred in Lahore in 1606. Similarly, Guru Hargobind had mandated his youngest son (Guru) Tegh Bahadur with the mission to revive the network of Guru Nanak's sangats as the Guru's Khalsa, a mission which he accomplished with total dedication but at the cost of his own lifexiv. Thus, such briefing was more apparent in Guruship successions from Guru Arjan onwards to ensure next-steps continuity in Guru Nanak Sahib's miri-piri (temporal and ideological) mission. It is almost certain from Bhat Bani that this tradition started with Guru Nanak Sahib when he passed on Guruship to Bhai Lehna as Guru Angad (Nanak II) and onwards.
Guru Gobind Singh's great grandfather, Guru Arjan (Fifth Nanak) and his father, Guru Tegh Bahadur (Ninth Nanak) had given one type of response to the bigotry of the rulers through their martyrdoms. He was destined to give another through armed defence. He would unite people from diverse backgrounds and turn them into invincible saint-warriors. The myth of Mughal superiority in the battlefield had already been exploded by the Sikh saint-warriors of his grandfather, Guru Hargobind.
Thus, the ultimate choice for responding to the urgency - imminent external threat hinted at - in Guru Tegh Bahadur's Bani, was clear. Aurungzeb's policy of converting all the sub-continent to Islam and establishing a one religion Islamic state was being ruthlessly pursued by overzealous regional commanders throughout the empire through forced mass conversions. Many Hindu sacred temples had been demolished. In addition there was tax - the jizya - imposed on non Muslims, also referred to in Guru Nanak Sahib's Asa ki Vaarxv.
Yet, this massive threat faced by young Guru Gobind Das belie the underlying strength of his heritage. As the successor of Guru Nanak, there was much which the Guru had inherited. The network of Guru Nanak's sangats had been revived by Guru Hargobind in the districts between Sutlej and Delhi and by the extensive parchaar (preaching) tours of Guru Tegh Bahadur which covered the Indian subcontinent and beyond. (see more under "Internal dissensions" below)
Physical fitness, marshal arts, swordsmanship and horse-riding had already become an established Sikh tradition progressively introduced from the time of Guru Angad (Nanak II) and continued by experienced tutors liked Baba Budha ji. The Sikh fighting skills were demonstrated in the battlefields of Amritsar and Kartarpur by the sahibzadas (sons) and the Sikhs of Guru Hargobind. The hitherto invincibility of professional Mughal generals and warriors had been shattered by the Guru and his trans-caste people's army in which the highest was equal to the lowest.
The Guru, and later, the Khalsa armies, had sustained supply of men and women (Singh-Singhania) warriors from different social backgrounds. Ordinary people sided with and willingly sheltered Sikh freedom fighters. The Mughal power, backed by a vast empire, was overwhelming at first but not sustainable over the decades as revolts broke out. Moderate Muslims too turned against the cruelty of the local nawabs. Egalitarian Khalsa institutions of langar, sharing, daswandhxvi and sewa (community service) sustained the Khalsa armies fighting the war of independence. They learnt about mutual interdependence as they fought for freedom from the invaders from the north-west collectively called the turaksxvii.
Spiritually and morally, the Panth of Guru Nanak, now led by Guru Gobind Singh was in a strong position against an empire which was already facing rebellions.
As Dr Gopal Singh wrote:
While the Guru had such a hostile array of forces against him, he also had many positive assets. His followers spread far and wide...made their offerings regularly, visited him at least once every year, and no sacrifice was too great for them in the Guru's cause. Mostly small peasants, artisan and traders ( though occasionally these also included sovereigns of state and rich merchants), their one aim in life was to achieve salvation through the Guru's door by seeking his benediction. It is them that the Guru wanted to organise into a more cohesive, more determined, more self-sacrificing group, cutting across all intermediaries like the masands, and infusing in them the spirit of nationhood as much as spiritual hope.xviii
Emperor Aurungzeb had further antagonised the Brahmins who had sought protection from Guru Tegh Bahadur, thus also acknowledging him as the True Guru on Guru Nanak Sahib's Gurgaddi.
The circumstances of the well-publicised unique martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur at Delhi for religious freedom, witnessed by the leaders of Islam, Hinduism and other religions and sects had sent a massive shock wave across the Indian subcontinent and beyond. Guru Gobind Singh was well aware of the great impact amongst the masses of Guru Tegh Bahadur's martyrdom which had added a new urgency to resist Aurungzeb's bigotry
Internal dissensions
Serious divisions in the Guru family had started when Prithi Chand, the eldest son of Guru Ramdas (Fourth Nanak) opposed the succession of his youngest brother, Guru Arjan as the Fifth Nanak in 1581. The disputes reached the emperors of Delhi in the years that followed. Many pretenders to Guruship had appeared at the village of Bakala following the demise of Guru Har Krishan (Eight Nanak) towards end March, 1675.
These internal divisions amongst the followers of Guru Nanak resulted in small gurudoms with own masands (regional representatives or preachers) touting their own guru business. Yet, a response to these internal rivalries had already been started by the Gurus before Guru Gobind Singh. Guru Hargobind (Sixth Nanak) had already started the process of linking the sangats directly with the Gurgaddi as the Guru's Khalsaxix. Later, the initiation of Khande ki pahul was introduced by Guru Gobind Singh on the Vaisakhi of 1699 when the full identity of the Khalsa was revealed.
This was a setback for the gurudoms and deras set up by the rivals in the Guru family and the masands. Thus, they were confined mostly to Punjab west of river Sutlej. In later years, following the battles of Anandpur in 1704, the loyalty of the sangats in the Malwa area (south and east of Sutlej) ensured Guru Gobind Singh's safe passage to Damdama Sahib and beyond.
Guruship impersonalised and the process of decision-making passed on to the Khalsa Panth
The process of impersonalising Guruship had in fact started with Guru Nanak Sahib. From the outset, the Guru preached the importance of Bani-Guru (Word Guru) enshrined in Guru Granth Sahib and Gur-Sangat (the holy congregation). Bhai Gurdas confirmed that the true image (moorat) of the Guru was the Guru's Shabd, the Guru's Word, or teaching. Guru Gobind Singh submitted himself to the collective will of the Khalsa by undergoing the Amrit initiation from the Panj Piaray (the Five Beloved Ones). He proclaimed that the Khalsa was in his own image and represented him.
After Guru Gobind Singh, by his own injunction, the Guruship continued from the person Guru to the joint Guruship of Bani Guru, Sri Guru Granth Sahib, and Gur Sangat as the Guru Khalsa.
He took up arms to resist bigotry and tyrannical rule to empower the ordinary people. He fought 14 battles between 1688 (Battle of Bhangani) and 1705 (Battle of Muktsar) against impossible odds to see the fall of the bigoted emperor Aurungzeb in 1707. He laid the foundation for the people's rule in Punjab as the Khalsa raj in which all were equal partners. He sacrificed his whole family and thousands of his beloved Khalsa gave their lives willingly for his cause, but he always remained in Chardhi Kalaa (in positive spirit while accepting God's Will).
Thus, Guru Gobind Singh ji completed his mission:
"For this purpose was I born: to spread righteous living, to raise the saintly people and to destroy the evil doers."
(Guru Gobind Singh, Bachittar Natak)
Truly there was and never will be another like Guru Gobind Singh, the greatest saint-warrior of all times.
References and notes:
i Dr J S Grewal, The Sikhs of Punjab, Cambridge University Press 1995, p 76
ii I was faced with this problem from the outset when invited to study the life and martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur ji in early 2016. The work was completed by April 2017 and published by the Sikh Missionary Society UK with the title, Guru Tegh Bahadur: The True Story.
iii Nirmala teachings incorporated Sikh teachings and doctrines within a largely Hindu/Vedantic framework. (http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Nirmala)
iv Nirmala teachings incorporated Sikh teachings and doctrines within a largely Hindu/Vedantic framework... In addition to the Adi Granth, they rely on the Vedas, Shastras, Puranas and Epic literature. http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Nirmala
v Pandas were professional genealogists at Hardwar.
vi Guru Kian Sakhian, (Punjabi) by Saroop Singh Koshish, edited and published by Piara Singh Padam, Singh Brothers, Amritsar 3rd edition 1995.
vii For further reading: Guru Gobind Singh's Date of Birth by Gurinder Singh Sacha
viii A sizeable group of men, women and children moving along like a caravan with carts, luggage and animals with armed guards. Prominent Sikh preachers accompanied the vaheer which made prolonged stops at sangat centres in India.
ix More about Guru Tegh Bahadur's keen interest in weapons and hunting in Guru Tegh Bahaur: The True Story, by the author, published by the Sikh Missionary Society UK 2017.
x Guru Tegh Bahadur's daily routine when he stayed at Lakhnaur with his family including (Guru) Gobind Das is well described by Koer Singh in his Gurbilas Patshahi 10 at p 42. Translation in the author's publication Guru Tegh Bahadur: The True Story,ibid, p 39
xi Hukamnamas of Guru Tegh Bahadur and the Bhat Vahis confirm Gobind Das as the Guru's name and not Gobind Rai.
xii "What was common to these crucial figures of the old Shaktas in the hills and the new Vaishnavas of the plains was the use of physical force made by the 'instruments' of God in favour of the good. The use of physical force was sanctioned by God" (Grewal JS, The Sikhs of Punjab, Cambridge University Press, 1995 p 76.)
xiii Dr J S Grewal, The Sikhs of Punjab, Ibid, p 71
xiv More about Guru Tegh Bahadur's mission in Guru Tegh Bahadur: The True Story, by this author,ibid..
xv Gaoo Brahman kau kar laavao Asa ki Vaar SGGS ang 471.
xvi Daswandh is contribution of one tenth of one's income for charitable causes.
xvii Turak (derived from Turk) is described as the enemy in Sikh writings and should be understood as referring to the cruel invaders from the north-west who terrorised ordinary people of all religions. Otherwise, Guru Gobind Singh had many Muslim supporters and companions. Muslims joined the Khalsa to repel these plunderers and played a prominent role in the powerful Khalsa army of Maharaja Ranjit Singh (1780-1839).
xviii Dr Gopal Singh Guru Gobind Singh, National Book Trust, India 1966, P.9.
xix Khalsa (a term derived from Mughal land law, as land belonging directly to the sovereign), were the Sikhs and sangats (congregations) who were directly linked to the Guru. They did not recognise the masands who were local preachers appointed by earlier Gurus, and who received offerings on behalf of the Guru. In time many started enriching themselves by keeping the offerings. Also, rival gurudoms appointed own masands. The whole system had become corrupt by the time of Guru Hargobind. Guru Gobind Singh punished the corrupt masands and abolished the system altogether by making all sangats his Khalsa..
© Copyright Gurmukh Singh (U.K.)
E-mail: sewauk2005@yahoo.co.uk
Please acknowledge quotations from this article
Articles may be published subject to prior approval by the author